A Halloween Guide to Prohibited IRA Transactions

Most self-directed IRA mistakes happen when people make assumptions, uninformed decisions or simply ignore the rules.

Consider what happened to Donna McNulty.

In 2015, she used a self-directed IRA to invest in a company she established to purchase gold and silver coins. Unfortunately, Donna stored the coins in a safe at home, believing this was allowed because the company owned them.

The U.S. Tax Court, however, disagreed.

The court ruled that taking personal possession of the coins resulted in taxable IRA distributions of $374,000 in 2015 and $37,380 in 2016. She and her husband also faced tax penalties.

The lesson for investors is important: Even when an investment itself is permitted, how you purchase, hold, and manage it can have significant tax consequences.

One area that deserves particular attention is the IRS’s prohibited transaction rules.

Halloween IRA

What Is a Prohibited IRA Transaction?

The IRS has rules designed to prevent investors from using their retirement accounts for personal financial benefit before retirement.

Under Internal Revenue Code Section 4975, certain transactions between an IRA and people connected to the account are prohibited.

These individuals are known as “disqualified persons.” They generally include you, your spouse, your parents and grandparents, your children and grandchildren, and the spouses of your children and grandchildren.

Certain businesses you or other disqualified persons own, as well as people providing services to your IRA or exercising control over its assets, may also fall under these rules.

Siblings, cousins, aunts, uncles, and friends aren’t automatically disqualified based on their family or personal relationship with you. However, their involvement in an investment may still raise concerns depending on the circumstances.

The key point is that you must keep your IRA investments separate from your personal financial interests and those of disqualified persons.

Common IRA Mistakes to Avoid

Some prohibited transactions are easy to overlook, particularly when investing in property or privately held businesses.

For example:

  • Renting to family: Allowing your child to live in a rental property owned by your IRA, even if they pay market rent.
  • Doing your own repairs: Personally renovating an IRA-owned property instead of hiring an independent contractor.
  • Investing in your own business: Using IRA funds to invest in a company you already own or control when the transaction would involve prohibited self-dealing.
  • Borrowing against your IRA: Using IRA assets as collateral for a personal loan, which can trigger a taxable distribution under a separate IRS rule.

The consequences can be substantial. If an IRA owner engages in a prohibited transaction, the entire account may lose its tax-advantaged status as of the first day of that year. The account’s value may become taxable, and an additional 10% early-distribution tax may apply if the investor is under age 59½.

Other disqualified persons involved in a prohibited transaction may also face excise taxes, generally starting at 15% of the amount involved, with an additional 100% tax potentially applying if the transaction isn’t corrected within the required period.

These penalties make it important to understand the rules before completing an investment.

How to Protect Your Self-Directed IRA

Before investing, consider who’s involved, whether you or someone connected to you might personally benefit, and how the investment will be managed.

Keep your personal finances separate from your IRA. Avoid using personal funds to pay expenses associated with IRA-owned investments, and don’t perform work on properties held in your IRA.

It’s also important to understand your custodian’s role.

Preferred Trust handles IRA account administration, paperwork, and required reporting. However, it doesn’t determine whether a transaction violates IRS prohibited transaction rules or provide investment, tax, or legal advice.

As an investor, you’re responsible for making sure your investments comply with IRS requirements. If you’re considering a transaction and aren’t sure whether it’s permitted, consult a qualified tax or legal advisor before committing your retirement funds.

Understanding these rules can help you make more informed decisions as you explore alternative investments with your self-directed IRA.

Explore Your Self-Directed IRA Investment Options

Learn how Preferred Trust helps investors use their retirement funds to invest in real estate, private lending, private equity, and other alternative assets.

Explore Your Investment Options

This article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal, tax, or investment advice. Consult a qualified tax advisor or attorney before executing any self-directed IRA transaction.

Share this article

In this article